THE 30-SECOND PULSE
219 Long Island listings failed in this week's MLS pull (Nov 14–19): 128 expired, 63 canceled, 28 withdrawn. Fresh failures, not recycled inventory.
The median failed single-family ask was $899,000, and only 17 of the 188 single-family failures asked under $600,000. The sub-$600K segment is where the Sheet lives, and it's scarce.
THE VERIFIED DEALS
No verified deals this week. Three properties cleared the mechanical screen, and all three failed verification. Two of them are actively listed again right now under new MLS numbers — the "expired" record was days old and already stale. The third was a 55+ condo unit priced at its own market, wearing a single-family valuation that didn't fit it. The Sheet doesn't run numbers it can't stand behind, so instead of padding the tier, the near-misses are on the watchlist below — every one of them checked this week, each with the price where it actually works.
THE WATCHLIST: deals that don't pencil at asking, with the price where they would
These are this week's expired/canceled/withdrawn listings that passed every eligibility screen but miss the Sheet's spread bar (a spread of at least $40K and 10% of price, run on conservative numbers) at their asking price. Every figure is a model estimate. "Pencils at" is a target price, not the asking price. It's the number you'd have to buy it at for the spread to clear the bar. Work them toward it.
MASTIC BEACH — 4BR/2BA, 1,176 sq ft, 11,326 sq ft lot
Situation: withdrawn at $449,000 after 49 days on market
Asking: $449,000
Est. ARV: ~$460,000 (valuation-model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$40,000 (cosmetic tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$29,000
Pencils at: ~$380,000
Why it's interesting: the smallest gap in this week's tier — the model value sits just over the ask, so the whole argument is about $69,000 of price on a 0.26-acre lot.
Next step: reply to this email.HICKSVILLE — 3BR/1BA, 1,148 sq ft, 5,001 sq ft lot
Situation: expired at $614,000 after 62 days on market; price cut in October; listed as an as-is sale
Asking: $614,000
Est. ARV: ~$621,000 (valuation-model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$35,000 (cosmetic tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$28,000
Pencils at: ~$533,000
Why it's interesting: the conservative model runs just over the ask — this one isn't a value argument either, it's the repair budget plus about $81,000 of price.
Next step: reply to this email.MASTIC — 3BR/1BA, 1,014 sq ft, 3,920 sq ft lot
Situation: canceled at $445,000 after 91 days on market
Asking: $445,000
Est. ARV: ~$430,000 (valuation-model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$30,000 (cosmetic tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$45,000
Pencils at: ~$360,000
Why it's interesting: three months of market exposure before it canceled, and the second value model runs about $57,000 higher than the conservative one — at $360,000, both models clear the bar.
Next step: reply to this email.FREEPORT — 4BR/2BA, 2,068 sq ft, 10,001 sq ft lot
Situation: expired at $799,999 after 87 days on market; listed at $849,999 in August and cut once before it expired
Asking: $799,999
Est. ARV: ~$808,000 (county sold-comp model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$65,000 (cosmetic tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$57,000
Pencils at: ~$675,000
Why it's interesting: the seller already moved $50,000 once and it still didn't sell. The comp model says roughly $125,000 more is where a 2,068 sq ft Freeport house starts to work.
Next step: reply to this email.FARMINGDALE — 4BR/2BA, 1,674 sq ft, 5,393 sq ft lot
Situation: expired at $799,000 after 88 days on market, after a $26,000 price drop during the listing
Asking: $799,000
Est. ARV: ~$772,000 (county sold-comp model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$55,000 (cosmetic tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$82,000
Pencils at: ~$651,000
Why it's interesting: last sold in 2020 for $490,000. The ask ran past both the comp model and the property's own history — $651,000 is where the math resets.
Next step: reply to this email.MASTIC — 3BR/2BA, 1,259 sq ft, 7,841 sq ft lot
Situation: canceled at $475,000 after 63 days on market; a short sale listed as needing a full interior renovation, subject to bank approval
Asking: $475,000
Est. ARV: ~$481,000 (valuation-model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$115,000 (heavy tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$109,000
Pencils at: ~$326,000
Why it's interesting: the renovation is the deal — the repair budget is bigger than the price gap, so scope discipline matters as much as the offer. Bank approval means a longer runway, and the price has to pay for that too.
Next step: reply to this email.SOUND BEACH — 3BR/2BA, 1,008 sq ft, 7,841 sq ft lot
Situation: withdrawn at $515,000 after 6 days on market; off-market status confirmed this week
Asking: $515,000
Est. ARV: ~$427,000 (valuation-model estimate, conservative leg)
Est. repairs: ~$30,000 (cosmetic tier estimate)
Spread at asking: ~-$118,000
Pencils at: ~$357,000
Why it's interesting: last sold in 2021 for $345,000, then withdrawn inside a week. The widest gap in the tier — a patience entry, not a this-week call. If it relists lower, it gets interesting fast.
Next step: reply to this email.
DEAL MATH: how every spread in the Sheet gets run
ARV comes from sold comps, not list prices. Repairs get estimated by condition tier before anyone calls a contractor. Gross spread is what's left after asking + repairs. That's the project, not the profit.
The watchlist is the deals that don't pencil at asking. Each one shows the price where the spread would clear our bar, so you can work them toward it instead of guessing.
CLOSE
Every Friday: off-market Long Island deals like these, numbers already run, while they're still off the MLS.
Founding members lock $29/mo for life. The first 25 only, then it's $49/mo. Upgrade: https://theislanddealsheet.com/upgrade